New York Minute (2004)

New York Minute arrives in 2004 as the second and final theatrical outing for the Olsen twins, a brand extension with a plot attached. Jane is the overachiever, Roxy the aspiring rock star, and Manhattan is the obstacle course. There is a truant officer, a smuggler, a microchip, a senator's son, and a dog that swallows the evidence. Dennie Gordon directs with efficiency. The film wants nothing more than to entertain, and it is honest about that.

The social consciousness on display is incidental. The cast is overwhelmingly white, with minority performers confined to supporting and background roles, most visibly in the Harlem salon sequence that critics flagged at the time for ethnic stereotyping. Stereotyping is a liability, not an argument. Two young women carry the picture and a woman sits in the director's chair, but the sisterhood here is a plot device, a mechanism for a third-act reconciliation, not a thesis. Nobody in this film is trying to teach anybody anything, and that is its most distinguishing feature.

There are no LGBTQ themes. No climate sermon. The piracy operation run out of Bennie Bang's mother's apartment is a comic obstacle, not a critique of capital. No body positivity, no neurodivergence, no history to revise. Roger Ebert proposed that the film should have gone through video and kept going to the end of the universe. That is harsh, though the $21.3 million gross against a $30 million budget lends the verdict some weight. It has since been re-evaluated as a cult classic, the customary consolation. Measured against the progressive markers of the present decade, the film is close to a null set: a teen comedy from a moment when a teen comedy could simply be one.

{"thematic_tags": []}