Disobedience (2018)

Sebastián Lelio's Disobedience opens with a sermon and closes with a kiss, which is a tidy summary of its concerns. Ronit, a New York photographer played by Rachel Weisz, returns to the Orthodox Jewish enclave of North London to bury a father who never quite forgave her. She finds her childhood friend Esti, played by Rachel McAdams, installed as the wife of the late rabbi's chosen successor. Dovid, played by Alessandro Nivola, is the third point of a triangle the script declines to resolve cheaply. The old attraction resumes with a deliberateness that borders on the liturgical. Lelio photographs the reunion in muted tones and lets long silences do the arguing.

The romantic core here is between two women, and the film takes that seriously without turning it into a seminar. Esti's confession that she has only ever been drawn to women arrives quietly, and her later request for freedom from her husband lands as an act of self-possession, not a slogan. The critique of arranged marriage and patriarchal expectation runs through the whole thing, though the film is careful to grant Dovid his dignity. The casting is largely Jewish, which lends the community its texture. The two leads remain, of course, white movie stars.

Where the film earns its restraint is in what it refuses. There is no racial argument, no economic argument, no environmental lament, no celebration of bodies, no diagnosis of neurodivergence, no reworking of the historical record. It is a contemporary story about faith, desire, and the cost of both. Reviewers noted that it never preaches, and that is accurate. The film sits in its own melancholy and declines to instruct us. For a picture built on transgression, it is remarkably unwilling to raise its voice. We file it accordingly, with a weary nod and a fresh pot of tea.

{"thematic_tags": ["book_adaptation"]}