Downton Abbey (2019)

Downton Abbey arrives as a two-hour reunion for an audience that already knows the seating chart. The Crawleys prepare for a royal visit in 1927, and the machinery of a stately home grinds into motion. Julian Fellowes writes with the confidence of a man who understands his parishioners. The stakes are a broken boiler, a misplaced chair, and the question of which servant will carry the soup. It is a film about the maintenance of order, and it loves that order without a flicker of doubt.

The progressive content is present but modest. A butler named Barrow, closeted and lonely, slips away to an underground nightclub in York, which the police raid with the usual enthusiasm. His rescue by the King's own valet offers a quiet, well-tailored plea for tolerance. Lady Mary seizes control of the estate, and the downstairs staff reclaim their kitchen from the royal entourage, gestures toward female competence and class solidarity that the film enjoys and then safely contains. The house endures. The hierarchy is restored. Everyone is home by supper.

On the ledger of modern social consciousness, this is a slender entry. The cast is white, the politics are nostalgic, and the film has no interest in interrogating the world it so lovingly reconstructs. There is no sermon here, no lecture, no moralizing. It is a warm bath drawn by a devoted staff, and it expects to be thanked. We score it accordingly, with the mild fatigue of a critic who has now watched the aristocracy win again, at length, and in excellent tailoring. The costumes are, it should be said, superb. The conscience of the piece remains folded neatly in a drawer, pressed and ready for a less complicated era.

A note on the royal staff, who arrive arrogant and are humbled by sedatives and locked doors: this is the closest the film comes to a political statement, and it retreats from the implications before the soup is served. The class critique is a party trick. The aristocracy is not indicted. It is celebrated, lit beautifully, and sent to bed.

Such is the classification. A gracious host, a firm handshake, and nothing that might unsettle the guests.

{"thematic_tags": ["box_office_number_one"]}