WMS

Up in the Air

2009 · Directed by Jason Reitman

🧘8

Woke Score

83

Critic

🍿78

Audience

Ultra Based

Critics rated this 75 points above its woke score. Among Ultra Based films, this critic score ranks #287 of 1469.

🎭🏳️‍🌈👑🌱💰💗🧠📖📢
Consciousness MeterUltra Based
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

Corporate downsizing expert Ryan Bingham spends his life in planes, airports, and hotels, but just as he's about to reach a milestone of ten million frequent flyer miles, he meets a woman who causes him to rethink his transient life.

Consciousness Assessment

Up in the Air exists as a curious artifact of pre-woke cinema attempting to grapple with contemporary economic collapse while remaining fundamentally incurious about the systemic conditions that produced it. The film diagnoses the symptoms of late capitalism with some acuity, observing the human cost of corporate restructuring through the eyes of a professional downsizer, yet it never extends its critique beyond the personal. Ryan Bingham, portrayed by George Clooney as a charismatic man-child, encounters the wreckage of other people's lives without experiencing meaningful transformation or reckoning. The narrative ultimately endorses the protagonist's emotional growth as sufficient resolution, a distinctly individualist approach to what was actually a systemic catastrophe affecting millions.

The cast presents an almost aggressively unmarked diversity, which is to say, the film casts actors of various backgrounds without comment or acknowledgment. Vera Farmiga and Anna Kendrick appear as fully realized characters whose lives and desires matter, though the film remains centered on the male protagonist's journey. The ensemble work is accomplished, but the structural inequality of attention remains unexamined. No character of color occupies a position of narrative significance, and the film's brief acknowledgment of gender dynamics never develops into anything resembling systematic critique.

Jason Reitman's direction emphasizes technical proficiency and narrative elegance over any sustained interrogation of the material. The film is fundamentally a romance dressed in the language of social commentary, more interested in whether Ryan will open his heart than whether he should have a conscience about his profession. In 2009, this calculus seemed sufficient. Viewed through the lens of contemporary sensibilities, the film's incuriousness about power structures and its privileging of personal redemption over collective responsibility reads as comfortably conventional, a work that mistakes sophistication for engagement.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

83%from 36 reviews
The Hollywood Reporter100

It's rare for a movie to be at once so biting and so moving. If Ryan's future seems bleak, there's something exhilarating about a movie made with such clear-eyed intelligence.

Stephen FarberRead Full Review →
Entertainment Weekly100

Up in the Air is light and dark, hilarious and tragic, romantic and real. It's everything that Hollywood has forgotten how to do; we're blessed that Jason Reitman has remembered

Owen GleibermanRead Full Review →
Chicago Sun-Times100

Up in the Air takes the trust people once had in their jobs and pulls out the rug. It is a film for this time.

Roger EbertRead Full Review →
Time Out40

Reitman, who also cowrote the screenplay, feels the constant need to "deepen" his characters, granting them wants and motivations--especially during the moralistic third act--that are totally alien to how they're initially portrayed.

Keith UhlichRead Full Review →