WMS

TÁR

2022 · Directed by Todd Field

🧘52

Woke Score

82

Critic

Woke-Adjacent

Critics rated this 30 points above its woke score. Among Woke-Adjacent films, this critic score ranks #29 of 151.

🎭🏳️‍🌈👑🌱💰💗🧠📖📢
Consciousness MeterWoke-Adjacent
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

As celebrated conductor Lydia Tár starts rehearsals for a career-defining symphony, the consequences of her past choices begin to echo in the present.

Consciousness Assessment

TÁR arrives as a carefully constructed psychological study of power, abuse, and institutional complicity, which is to say it arrives as a film more interested in moral texture than in cultural messaging. Todd Field's direction and Cate Blanchett's performance create a portrait of a woman whose professional achievements and personal charisma have insulated her from accountability until they cannot. The film's central achievement lies not in making us comfortable with simple judgments about its protagonist, but in forcing us to reckon with how privilege operates across gender lines.

The film's engagement with progressive sensibilities remains oblique and sometimes contradictory. Lydia Tár's position as the first female conductor of a major German orchestra could read as triumphant, but instead the narrative uses it as a foundation for examining how women in power can replicate the very abusive dynamics they theoretically oppose. Her same-sex marriage, rather than being a statement of inclusion, provides domestic texture without ideological weight. The film seems interested in demonstrating that gender, sexuality, and institutional achievement do not automatically confer moral clarity on those who possess them.

We observe most forcefully a film that views its subject matter with a kind of anthropological detachment. There is no cathartic reckoning, no redemptive arc, no lecture about systemic change. Instead, we watch a brilliant woman's careful world collapse through the accumulation of small refusals to acknowledge her own complicity. This is not the work of a filmmaker interested in advancing a particular social agenda so much as one interested in the specific architecture of a particular human failure. The result is a film that progressive audiences might expect to endorse certain positions, only to find themselves confronted with something far more ambiguous and, perhaps, more honest about the limits of personal transformation.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

82%from 5 reviews
iNews.co.uk100

A cut above in terms of style, performance, and ideas, Todd Field's film about a celebrity conductor accused of sexual misconduct is essential cinema.

Christina NewlandRead Full Review →
Sydney Morning Herald90

The film is a genuine tragedy -- a black comic tragedy, but a tragedy nonetheless.

Sandra HallRead Full Review →
Book & Film Globe80

Field narrows his focus and settles instead on the film being a sumptuously told but ultimately straightforward comeuppance cautionary tale of supreme arrogance supremely humbled.

Stephen GarrettRead Full Review →
Cinéfilo Serial70

It's an interesting film that could easily be based on real events, but it's a captivating fiction due to the themes and concerns it raises.

Samantha SchusterRead Full Review →