WMS

Monsters vs Aliens

2009 · Directed by Rob Letterman

🧘22

Woke Score

56

Critic

🍿64

Audience

Based

Critics rated this 34 points above its woke score. Among Based films, this critic score ranks #271 of 346.

🎭🏳️‍🌈👑🌱💰💗🧠📖📢
Consciousness MeterBased
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

When Susan Murphy is unwittingly clobbered by a meteor full of outer space gunk on her wedding day, she mysteriously grows to 49-feet-11-inches. The military jumps into action and captures Susan, secreting her away to a covert government compound. She is renamed Ginormica and placed in confinement with a ragtag group of Monsters.

Consciousness Assessment

Monsters vs Aliens stands as a relic of the pre-woke animation era, a period when films could feature female protagonists without the accompanying infrastructure of cultural commentary. The film's central conceit, Susan Murphy's transformation from wedding-day casualty to giant warrior, contains the skeleton of a feminist narrative, but the meat has been stripped away in favor of conventional action beats and comedic set pieces. Her rejection of her fiancé and embrace of her new identity might read differently to contemporary audiences, yet the film treats this primarily as plot mechanics rather than as conscious cultural statement.

The casting choices present a diverse array of voice actors, but this diversity functions as a source of comedy rather than as representation worthy of examination. The monster squad includes characters of various sizes, shapes, and temperaments, yet the film makes no attempt to explore what this diversity might signify. We are meant to laugh at the incongruity of the team, not to contemplate their significance. The film's sensibilities remain fundamentally those of early-2000s family entertainment, concerned with spectacle and humor rather than with the social architecture that would later become central to mainstream animation.

The absence of LGBTQ+ themes, climate consciousness, anti-capitalist positioning, or any form of what we might now recognize as progressive lecture energy marks this as a film produced in a different era. It is not hostile to such sensibilities, merely indifferent to them. In the landscape of contemporary cinema, this indifference itself becomes notable, a reminder of how thoroughly cultural expectations have shifted in little more than a decade.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

56%from 35 reviews
Portland Oregonian83

Pure, light entertainment.

Shawn LevyRead Full Review →
Village Voice80

The grandeur of the effects--the honest-to-God spectacle of the thing--elevates Monsters vs. Aliens to something approaching art. It's not a masterpiece, but it's most certainly a milestone.

Robert WilonskyRead Full Review →
Slate80

The richly multilayered picture tends to have a gently immersive effect, akin to a stroll through the world's most expensive diorama.

Jessica WinterRead Full Review →
New York Post25

Dreamworks Animation's clunky and wildly unimaginative Monsters vs. Aliens really doesn't have a clue what to do with the [3-D] technique.

Lou LumenickRead Full Review →