WMS

M3GAN

2022 · Directed by Gerard Johnstone

🧘22

Woke Score

72

Critic

🍿66

Audience

Based

Critics rated this 50 points above its woke score. Among Based films, this critic score ranks #140 of 346.

Consciousness MeterBased
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

A brilliant toy company roboticist uses artificial intelligence to develop M3GAN, a life-like doll programmed to emotionally bond with her newly orphaned niece. But when the doll's programming works too well, she becomes overprotective of her new friend with terrifying results.

Consciousness Assessment

M3GAN represents the baseline of contemporary representation without pushing particularly hard in any direction. The film places a competent woman in a leadership role within a tech company, a choice that feels more like industry standard casting than a deliberate statement. Allison Williams brings credibility to the role of Gemma, a roboticist, and her technical expertise is never questioned by the narrative, though neither is it particularly foregrounded as remarkable. The supporting cast includes racial diversity that appears organically distributed rather than performatively assembled, which counts for something in an industry still learning how to cast films naturally.

The film's engagement with progressive sensibilities largely ends there. While it features an orphaned child and explores themes of parental responsibility and emotional bonds, these are treated as plot mechanics rather than opportunities for social commentary. There is no discernible LGBTQ+ representation, no climate consciousness, no anti-capitalist messaging despite the corporate setting, and no meaningful engagement with neurodivergence or body diversity. The film is, fundamentally, a commercial horror product designed to entertain rather than educate.

What emerges from M3GAN is a film comfortable with surface-level contemporary casting norms but unwilling to interrogate them or build thematic weight around them. It is the cinematic equivalent of a diversity checkbox executed competently but without conviction. For audiences seeking either authentic progressive storytelling or a thoughtful critique of technology and capitalism, the film offers little beyond its efficient genre mechanics.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

72%from 55 reviews
Collider91

M3GAN might just become the Malignant of 2023. It doesn’t have a twist, but it is a weird, bonkers movie. Director Gerard Johnstone knocked it out of the park with his second film. It’s not traditionally scary, but it is existentially scary. As the world makes greater strides in AI and robotics, these kinds of scenarios become more terrifyingly possible. Luckily, you have the strange image of M3GAN twerking or driving an expensive sports car to make you giggle past the discomfort.

Consequence91

Cautionary tales about the dangers of life in the Internet age can often feel heavy-handed and trite, but M3GAN never feels like an extended Black Mirror episode. Its accessible themes don’t come off as oversaturated, thanks to the wit of the screenplay and a great performance from Williams.

Cady SiregarRead Full Review →
TheWrap90

Johnstone’s film captures the same alchemical blend of heart, humor and havoc you find only rarely, in crossover classics like “Gremlins,” and it yields more entertainment than most would-be blockbusters.

William BibbianiRead Full Review →
San Francisco Chronicle50

At its titanium core, M3GAN is a mostly on-the-mark commentary on our tech dependence.

Carla MeyerRead Full Review →