WMS

Love, Simon

2018 · Directed by Greg Berlanti

🧘68

Woke Score

72

Critic

🍿80

Audience

Woke

Critics rated this 4 points above its woke score. Among Woke films, this critic score ranks #54 of 89.

🎭🏳️‍🌈👑🌱💰💗🧠📖📢
Consciousness MeterWoke
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

Everyone deserves a great love story, but for 17-year-old Simon Spier, it's a little more complicated. He hasn't told his family or friends that he's gay, and he doesn't know the identity of the anonymous classmate that he's fallen for online.

Consciousness Assessment

Love, Simon arrives as a competent, if somewhat cautious, entry in the mainstreaming of LGBTQ+ teen cinema. The film concerns itself primarily with the experience of a privileged gay teenager whose greatest obstacles appear to be social embarrassment rather than material hardship or genuine danger, a choice that speaks volumes about its intended audience and the cultural moment of its release. Greg Berlanti constructs a narrative that treats coming out as the central dramatic crisis of American adolescence, which is not inaccurate so much as narrowly focused on a particular demographic reality. Simon's sexuality is presented as entirely normal within the film's universe, and his journey toward self-acceptance and romantic fulfillment follows the exact template of heterosexual teen romances, which carries both progressive and limiting implications.

The film's progressive sensibilities manifest most clearly in its straightforward affirmation of homosexuality as a non-issue requiring celebration rather than debate. The supporting cast includes students of various racial backgrounds in organic roles, though the narrative remains firmly centered on Simon's emotional development, and the film offers little engagement with how identity intersects across multiple axes. Where Love, Simon demonstrates genuine commitment to its thematic project is in its refusal to treat the closet as psychologically necessary or the coming-out process as anything other than fundamentally positive. The film offers no counterargument to its central thesis, which could be read as either admirably confident or somewhat preachy depending on one's tolerance for narrative certainty.

By 2018 standards, this represented a significant cultural statement about the normalization of LGBTQ+ youth in mainstream American cinema. The film's tonal lightness and romantic comedy framework necessarily limit the depth of its engagement with more complex dimensions of queer experience, but its existence as a mainstream studio production centering a gay protagonist marks a measurable shift in what Hollywood considers commercially viable. Love, Simon occupies the role of the well-meaning middle ground, neither revolutionary nor complacent, a film that affirms rather than interrogates.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

72%from 38 reviews
Rolling Stone88

Love, Simon is a John Hughes movie for audiences who just got woke. And for all its attempts not to offend, it's a genuine groundbreaker.

Peter TraversRead Full Review →
The Associated Press88

Love, Simon is a universal story, even if you’re not a gay teenager. The challenge of figuring out who we are and standing comfortably in that identity might begin in high school, but often lasts a lifetime.

Sandy CohenRead Full Review →
Boston Globe88

It’s not exactly like the novel, but it captures the best parts of it.

Meredith GoldsteinRead Full Review →
The Film Stage50

Over two shapeless hours, it walks through sequences that announce their emotional gravitas while only sporadically earning it.

Daniel SchindelRead Full Review →

Consciousness Markers

🎭
Representation Casting68

The cast includes actors of various racial and ethnic backgrounds in supporting roles, though the narrative remains centered on a white gay protagonist. Diversity exists but is not the story's primary focus.

🏳️‍🌈
LGBTQ+ Themes92

The entire film is structured around LGBTQ+ identity and the coming-out experience. A gay teenager is the protagonist, and his journey toward self-acceptance and romance is treated with complete affirmation and normalcy.

👑
Feminist Agenda35

The film features female characters but they function primarily as supporting players in Simon's narrative. The feminist content is limited to background representation rather than thematic engagement.

Racial Consciousness42

While the film includes diverse casting, there is minimal explicit engagement with racial identity or racial consciousness. Characters of color are present but their experiences are not centered or explored.

🌱
Climate Crusade0

No evidence of climate-related themes or environmental consciousness in this teen romance narrative.

💰
Eat the Rich0

The film contains no critique of capitalism or class structures. Simon's world is firmly situated within suburban middle-class normalcy.

💗
Body Positivity0

No explicit body positivity messaging or engagement with non-standard body representation in this conventionally cast romance film.

🧠
Neurodivergence0

No representation or engagement with neurodivergent characters or themes in the narrative.

📖
Revisionist History0

The film makes no attempt to revise or reframe historical narratives. It is set in a contemporary high school environment.

📢
Lecture Energy48

While the film treats its LGBTQ+ affirmations as self-evident rather than debatable, its tonal lightness and romantic comedy framework prevent it from adopting an overtly preachy or preachy tone.