WMS

All the President's Men

1976 · Directed by Alan J. Pakula

🧘4

Woke Score

84

Critic

🍿81

Audience

Ultra Based

Critics rated this 80 points above its woke score. Among Ultra Based films, this critic score ranks #275 of 1469.

Consciousness MeterUltra Based
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

During the 1972 elections, two reporters' investigation sheds light on the controversial Watergate scandal that compels President Nixon to resign from his post.

Consciousness Assessment

This meticulous procedural examines institutional corruption through the lens of two white male journalists uncovering presidential malfeasance. The film remains admirably committed to its subject matter: the mechanics of investigative journalism, the importance of institutional accountability, and the danger posed by unchecked executive power. One must acknowledge that these are serious themes worthy of serious treatment, yet they belong to an older political vocabulary, one concerned with structural checks and balances rather than the constellation of social consciousness markers that define contemporary progressive sensibilities.

The supporting cast includes women in minor roles, most notably Jane Alexander as a Post employee, but they exist in the margins of a narrative that treats the investigation itself as the only matter of consequence. The film offers no commentary on gender dynamics, no interrogation of identity, no celebration of diversity as a value in itself. The newsroom and the corridors of power are occupied by men who speak in clipped tones about facts and corroboration. This is not because the filmmakers were hostile to progressive concerns, but because such concerns had not yet assumed their current cultural centrality.

What emerges is a film of genuine historical importance but minimal contemporary social consciousness. It champions the institutional safeguards of a liberal democracy, not the cultural frameworks that emerged decades later. For those seeking evidence of 2020s progressive sensibilities, this remains barren ground.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

84%from 18 reviews
Empire100

One of modern American film’s most intelligent and provocative accounts of a nation’s political failings, and a near-perfect depiction of journalism at its purist and most inspired. To be more succinct, it is quite brilliant.

Ian NathanRead Full Review →
Entertainment Weekly100

Based on Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein’s best-seller about cracking the byzantine Watergate cover-up, the movie is a victory lap for American journalism — the triumphant flip side to Network‘s self-loathing take on the media.

Chris NashawatyRead Full Review →
Chicago Tribune100

This edgy but highly polished movie established the modern myth of journalists-as-heroes: crusaders in the service of the Constitution. [14 Nov 2008, p.C7]

Maureen M. HartRead Full Review →
Chicago Reader50

Alan Pakula's pedestrian 1976 recap of Watergate is a study in missed opportunities.